Andy Duncan's Profile

Message Reviews Cellar Shopping List

Bio

(Andy hasn't revealed anything yet.)

Location: Hermosa Beach, California, United States

You must be signed in before you can comment.

Recent Reviews & Comments

Everything Only: Reviews | Andy’s Comments | Others’ Comments

2006 Scholium Project Gardens of Babylon Tenbrink Vineyards
(2009-02-01 19:20:37 UTC) buddy icon 2006 Scholium Project Gardens of Babylon Tenbrink Vineyards 85/100

Ignore the numerical rating, it's difficult to score this wine.

This is Petite Sirah Port.

Decanted for two hours, this is a massive, blueberries-and-tannins monster.

Thick, dark, juicy. All 16.8% of the alcohol is there on the finish but not so much on the nose.

It's a well made wine but definitely not a table wine at this point, we busted out some dark chocolate to go with it and had it for dessert.

I'm guessing this will last just about forever, or at least as long as you would age port.

Tasting Tags:

2006 Roessler La Brisa Sonoma Coast
(2009-02-01 19:11:24 UTC) buddy icon 2006 Roessler La Brisa Sonoma Coast 88/100

Spicier and bigger than the "Red Label" of the same vintage, but still on the restrained and elegant side of cali pinot. A little more complexity than the red label, small amount of barnyard and earth.

2006 Roessler Red Label Sonoma County Pinot Noir
(2009-02-01 19:08:08 UTC) buddy icon 2006 Roessler Red Label Sonoma County Pinot Noir 88/100

Quite tasty, very sultry. Nice lightweight elegant pinot. A little on the simple side, but very drinkable. Pretty.

2005 Ty Caton Field Blend Red
(2009-01-26 00:12:41 UTC) buddy icon 2005 Ty Caton Field Blend Red 85/100

Big, jammy, with dark candied fruit. Well made wine, just not quite my style.

Tasting Tags:

1987 Stags' Leap Petite Sirah
(2009-01-26 00:10:05 UTC) buddy icon 1987 Stags' Leap Petite Sirah 91/100

Tasted Jan 2009. Terrific bouquet, still recognizably Petite Sirah and showing quite a bit of life for a 21+ year old wine.

2003 White Crane Folkendt Estate Cabernet Sauvignon
(2008-12-25 06:52:17 UTC) buddy icon 2003 White Crane Folkendt Estate Cabernet Sauvignon 80/100

Huge, overripe, late-harvest-zin-like with alcohol and mint on the nose. Technically fine, other than the alcohol (which seems to be more pungent than the listed 14.6%) but any complexity, cab-like character or indication that it came from Livermore have been lost.

Tasting Tags:

1999 Saxon Brown Pinot Noir Russian River Valley
(2008-11-06 05:18:49 UTC) buddy icon 1999 Saxon Brown Pinot Noir Russian River Valley 90/100

Mushrooms. Like crazy, eerily mushroom-y mushrooms. Some earth, and lots of interesting floral bottle bouquet. Tart, and might even last a few more years if you're into that sort of thing.

Tasting Tags:

2003 Penfolds Bin 28 Kalimna Shiraz
(2008-10-06 16:59:52 UTC) buddy icon 2003 Penfolds Bin 28 Kalimna Shiraz 88/100

Good acidity and some bottle complexity, but a little fake fruit poking through.

Tasting Tags:

2005 Noceto Sangiovese
(2008-10-01 01:10:43 UTC) buddy icon 2005 Noceto Sangiovese 81/100

Nothing wrong with this wine, it's just not interesting. It's not acidic enough to be that good with food, and it's certainly not interesting enough to be self-supporting.

This is a fruit-driven wine, and if you like fruit in your wine, you'll probably like this more than me. But to me it was one-dimensional and uninteresting.

Tasting Tags:

2004 Chateau Peyredon-Lagravette
(2008-08-28 04:52:53 UTC) buddy icon 2004 Chateau Peyredon-Lagravette 88/100

Earth and spice on the nose, some old world funk. Good amount of berry and cassis. A little bit of acrid oak on the finish. Nice, and definitely good for the price. Soft tannins.